Thursday, 16 September 2021

Knowing That What You Have Is Not What You Have


 “Purpose is the essential element of you. It is the reason you are on the planet at this particular time in history. Your very existence is wrapped up in the things you are here to fulfill.” – Chadwick Boseman

 

The perpetual quest for purpose is an endless tedious pursuit, that consumes us from the moment we set foot into this mundane world. Its concept and ideas, are often discussed and imparted to us at various tenets of our lives, ranging from early childhood to our early twenties, and is often wrapped up and tied to the notions of identity and meaning. Purpose is how we comprehend our place in the world, as well as the means through which we seek to gauge an understanding of why we are here at this particular time, how we may use this time effectively, and meaningfully live our assigned life to the fullest.

Picture this: a bunch of individuals are randomly selected and casually placed all over a planet called Earth. Each of them are aware that their stay is limited, although they are unaware as to when it would expire. They are surrounded by suffering and horrifying events that scar them, and question the brutal nature of humanity. From family, friends, colleagues, to the limitations and the susceptibility of their body to diseases, they are enclosed in a cycle of both physical and mental suffering, wreaked upon them and the rest of the world, with no explanation for its presence, as well as our existence.

This type of situation inevitably leads to a realization of our material, mundane insignificance, in relation to the vast significant nature of the cosmos, which in turn results into a vicious downward spiral of manifested existential crises, due to the incomprehensibility of our existence. The notion of serving a greater purpose, being part of a larger scheme of things, along with the assumption that our presence and actions have some great cosmic meaning behind them is developed as a coping mechanism. Classic phrases such as ‘everything happens for a reason’, come into play to soften the blow of that realization, and a sense of purpose is attached to every incident and action, in order to add meaning to our state of existence. After all, our will to live significantly diminishes when we realize that there is no meaning in life, if nothing we do or experience, matter in the greater scheme of things.

The problem with placing our life’s focus in either seeking or achieving a sense of purpose, as a coping mechanism to our limited existence, is that purpose, like everything else is temporary and inconsistent. When we place our faith and focus on such states, it can negatively impact our quality of life, regardless of whether the purpose is fulfilled or not.

This impact can be explored through an illustration of two events.

The first instance revolves around an individual whose sole purpose is to become one of the leading actresses in the film industry, and earn millions along with recognition for her craft. She quits college in pursuit of her passion, and finally after struggling to establish herself she earns worldwide recognition.

However, while she was prepared to be a full time actress, and forfeit her privacy to be a face of the public, she also encounters a lot of biases and negative attention. Additionally, she finds that acting in movies no longer invokes the same zeal, passion and joy that once drove her. The hectic schedules appear to be monotonous, and the fanatical behavior of the fans and the general public which once thrilled her, has now been transformed into a source of anxiety and extreme discomfort. All the recognition and money obtained from years of hard work, sacrifice and dedication seem meaningless when viewed in retrospect, and the actress now enters into a state of hopelessness, dejection, and frustration.

The second instance deals with a passionate writer who is struggling to get her first publication. This individual also driven by passion and purpose, has dedicated years of study to the craft of writing, has taken up numerous writing courses, studied literature, as well as published numerous blogs and creative pieces on numerous forums. Additionally, the book that she is attempting to publish has taken her nearly four years to complete, because of the excess research and study dedicated to perfecting her work. Each trip to a publisher has only been met with harsh criticism and blatant rejection. Writing is her passion, a craft she has been honing and improving since her teenage years, only to result in no one willing to give her book a chance to be read. Gradually, the writer descends into a state of absolute dejection and frustration at the lack of opportunities present.

Both instances involve two artists driven by passion to achieve their sole purpose, which is recognition for their craft. The actress having fulfilled her purpose is frustrated because all her success and recognition now appear to be meaningless once it was finally achieved. The writer on the other hand, is equally frustrated due to the inability and lack of opportunities that are a barrier in fulfilling her purpose. The above two individuals highlight how the devotion to purpose results in feelings of inadequacy and frustration, irrespective of the it being fulfilled or not. When purpose is tied to identity and treated as a goal that needs to be achieved, its impact on one’s state of being is negative and detrimental.

The link between identity and purpose is detrimental, as both facets are extremely fluid in nature, and completely independent of each other. Numerous accounts of individuals who have embarked upon various journeys and endeavors in the pursuit of attempting to unravel ‘who they are’ (i.e. discover their identity), and ‘what it is they are meant to do’ (the search for purpose), have been recounted.

The irony of such a pursuit lies in the fact that identity comprises of a collection of abstract notions bound together, and thus cannot be unraveled or ‘discovered’ by simply travelling or embarking upon certain endeavors. Furthermore, as stated previously both facets are independent and do not equate the other. Identity is not wrapped up in purpose, and treating it as such results in an inability to function without purpose. This becomes problematic, as it disrupts our quality of life, leading to a state of hopelessness and frustration, as depicted through the above two illustrated events. When we feel that the lack of purpose distorts our identity, and cripples our ability to experience an enriching and fulfilling life, we operate under a mentality reflective of what could be termed as ‘self-imposed slavery’, simply due to the inability to fathom a life devoid of purpose.

At this point, we have established that the search for purpose is a futile endeavor, and the association that identity is wrapped up in purpose, is a detrimental notion that hinders a stable mentality, and results in an impairment of our quality of life. We have also exhibited how purpose adds fuel to our being, without which our will to live is imminently compromised.

Thereby, in order to achieve some form of resolution, two significant facets must be explored and discussed in order to formulate a solution that will provide some sense of closure, or at least divulge some understanding, to avoid falling into the pit of existential crises.

If purpose is the driving force behind individuals, then the abolishment of such an ideal would inherently be absurd and impractical. Furthermore, if the complete surrender to purpose, to the extent that identity becomes an inherent part of it, is reflective of slave mentality, then one would first have to establish what it takes to be a ‘free individual’.

As mentioned previously, the notion of identity is a composition of layers filled with abstract ideals tightly bound together. When tackling the notion of identity, the lens of Buddhism proves to be the most appropriate approach for such a task. Buddhism encourages detachment and the art of letting go, and even argues that our concept of ‘self’ is simply based on a mental construction, that our entire life is spent trying to free ourselves from, which in reality, entraps individuals more than providing some sense of identity and closure.

All our lives, we have been surrounded with various platforms and communities that encourage us to discover our identity. Various philosophers stated that the purpose of each individual during their lifetime, is to uncover their identity and discover who they truly are, and declare that an unexamined life is a life not worth living.  Hence, such phrases such as Socrates’s ‘know thyself’ have been transformed into everyday proverbial wisdom. Often primary school teachers have subjected their young pupils to the very question that takes a lifetime to answer, and still remains inconclusive up to date, by handing their pupils the dreaded and most absurd essay topic famously titled ‘Who Am I’.

Yet Buddhism on the other hand, denounces such pursuits and is more concerned with the layers of abstract and material ideals that form our mental construction, and encourages us to break free from such concepts through a gradual process of detachment. Most often the word ‘detachment’ has been used synonymously with the term ‘indifference’, therefore prior to the exploration of the path of detachment, the distinction between the two terms must be clarified, and shall be done through illustrated events.

Picture a lake. It is filled with images of the trees and the vast blue sky, coupled with the occasional flocks of birds that traverse the sky, the insects that perch on the banks, as well as the humans that stroll pass, and take a moment to peer into its depths. These images are all been reflected in the still water of the lake. Now imagine that a person comes by and flings a couple of pebbles in to the lake. As we all know, such an act temporarily disrupts the stillness of the water, causing a surge of ripples across the surface, before resuming its motionless state.

If we take the lake as a metaphor for the human mind, every experience, incident and feeling should ideally be observed from a distance with a calm objective mindset as much as possible. Just like how the lake reflects its surroundings but does not absorb anything, the mind should observe each incident and feeling, without getting affected by what it sees or experiences. Additionally, when individuals come and throw pebbles, which is an allusion to the disruptive forces, that most often arrive in the form of difficult people, represents how their forces could disrupt the peace and tranquility of our mind. However, once the ripples of disruption pass, our minds should resume its stillness. This is called detachment: when the forces of the world cannot penetrate but can be reflected and observed as distant images, and the individual remains unaffected by its forces in the face of it all.

Now envision a scenario where an individual remains completely unfazed and untouched by anything: a man completely devoid of the ability to feel anything, witnessing the death of a family member, feels no different than watching your child win an achievement award. The individual is unable to experience or exhibit any sign of remorse, joy, frustration, or even a hint of embarrassment.

Often at some point of our lives, each of us have desperately wished that we could cast off this exasperating inbuilt device known as emotion, and be free from its influence, which is known to cause more pain than joy, in a world rampant with suffering. However, lack of emotion upsets the equilibrium of the mental state, as its absence results in the inability to experience feelings, which not only hinders the ability to express emotion, but thwarts the ability to maintain good relationships, as one would be unable to comprehend the feelings of others and act accordingly.

An individual who cannot feel or understand the feelings of others is not detached but indifferent. Such individuals are unable to live an emotionally rich and fulfilling life due to their indifference, and thus are unable to appreciate and enjoy the small wonders and the simpler things life has to offer. Additionally, those who resort to extreme indifference where nothing in the world can arouse a single hint of emotion, where they are completely devoid of hope, as well as adopt the extremely pessimistic view that all values are inherently baseless, and condemns existence, find themselves on the further end of the indifference spectrum known as nihilism. Nihilists not only believe that life is meaningless, but also view other aspects of existence such as action and suffering, as empty and senseless.

The process of detachment is a long gradual one that like many other practices such as meditation, appear to be simple in theory, but extremely challenging to adopt as a drill that is followed diligently. It is the tightrope that stretches between nihilism and as discussed, self-imposed slavery. This process shall be thoroughly explored and outlined in three stages namely;

1.     Societal and material detachment

2.     Abstract detachment

3.     Detachment of the soul from the body

 

Societal and material detachment

This process of detachment is the first step and it involves the removal of all things and concepts that are regarded as worldly and material, and quite often such worldly possessions are linked and representative of the society and communities that surround us. Firstly, one would ideally attempt to distance themselves from all the material wealth, such as their luxuries, privileges, personal achievements and everything that is linked with their career or position in society. If this is done successfully, the individual would no longer feel the pull towards achievement, wealth, fame, and social status, and understand that such elements are not an inherent part of identity, and treating it as such is a futile and detrimental approach.

Gradually, the individual would develop an immunity to the raging torrent of ‘hustle culture’, and realize that true wealth lies in good health, peace of mind and mindfulness, and not in the endless material highs often chased by man. Such individuals would also grasp and adopt the ideal that the ultimate goal, is not what should be glorified but, that the journey to reach the goal, is what actually matters. This is due to the simple reason that the journey as well as the experiences that come along its way, is what shapes individuals and aids them in their growth, provided that they act with awareness and an inextinguishable will to learn.

Next, individuals would examine their resident community, and its members. This element of detachment is one of the most challenging, as it includes people that are so close to the extent that they appear to be an inseparable aspect of one’s identity. Such people happen to be their parents, siblings, as well as those who are not blood related, yet equally as closely knit as their family members, and those who fall under the umbrella term ‘chosen family’, such as newly inducted family members, friends, and pursued love interests. A majority are unable to fathom a life without their family and friends in particular, and the inevitable loss that accompanies such close knit relationships, are sufficient to completely disintegrate, or dismantle our state of being.

Family and friends are an integral part of our foundation, and are tightly woven into our identity, as their absence causes voids that can never be filled, and possesses the capacity to destabilize our state of being. The detachment of such closely knit relationships, results in the realization that their closeness does not define our identity, and that ultimately they too are fellow travelers in this journey of life, who have their own story to write. Detaching yourself from them means neither a lack of acknowledgement and appreciation for their presence, nor an invalidation of their role. It simply means that you acknowledge that they aren’t special, no matter how much love is shared, and that they don’t define you. While this does not ease the pain of their absence, it provides an understanding of their temporary existence, which makes us value them graciously enough to let them go when the time is right, and not fall apart when they do. It also eases the guilt and burden experienced when we make difficult life choices, when we are able to understand that neither belongs to the other, and that each is following their own path.

Finally, one would attempt to distance themselves from other societal constructions such as nationality, race, religion, gender, etc… They realize that none of the above factors are concrete, absolute definitive elements that constitute facets of our identity, and frankly that such facets cause more division, disharmony and prejudice, rather than provide a sense of belonging and individuality. Such elements are fragile concepts that society enforces to create a false sense of belonging. Individuality is gained not by upholding such concepts, but by casting them off and understanding that it transcends them, as humans are more than their societal markers, their material wealth as well as their close knit family and support systems.

 

Abstract detachment

Once the individual is able to shed their outer layer which consists of the societal connections and worldly material, they attempt to distance themselves of the second layer of detachment, which comprises of abstract ideals, that form the basis and cover of one’s identity. This stage of detachment can also be referred to as the removal of the ‘ideas of self’.

As stated on numerous occasions, the concept of identity is a mental construction that is tightly wrapped up in layers of abstract ideals. These layers of abstract ideals usually comprise of facets such as belief, faiths, opinions, values, preferences and ideas. This is even more challenging to let go, as most of us refuse to compromise such concepts especially when it comes to beliefs and values, and tend to latch onto such elements the way one would cling onto a canister of oxygen.

Detaching oneself from such abstract ideals, contrary to popular belief is not detrimental, and does not deter individuals from experiencing growth and development. When we let go of the idea of self, we create freedom and space to act and grow, as we don’t have an identity that is so fragile to the extent that it requires safeguarding and protection. Additionally, when such individuals are attacked, accused or framed, they remain calm, nonchalant and do not lose their composure, due to the simple reason that they have liberated themselves from the mental prison of abstract ideals, and no longer feel the need to defend them, or to safeguard their reputation.

 

Detachment of the soul from the body

The final stage of the process of detachment, which is an absolute form of detachment, as it involves succumbing to the notion that ‘the self’ simply ceases to exist. This stage is also termed as the ‘removal of self’. It is the realization that the body is a vehicle that a traveler is gifted with to voyage the journey of life, and thus it is not an inherently definitive part of one’s self. Individuals at this stage begin to comprehend the nature of the body, and appreciate it for all the vital organs that make the body work, and do not see any use in maintaining its outer appearance that is bound to deteriorate. They understand that it’s the inner organs that matter, as they protect and enable the working of the body, and not its outer appearances that make a difference in its ability to function.

Such individuals who are able to distance themselves from their body, have reached a high stage of detachment, which makes them immune to all the body shaming, glamor, and glorification, of body stereotypes, that are often perpetrated by our society, and further enhanced through the use of social media.

Additionally, individuals who manage to accomplish this state of detachment, and immunity, are able to embark, and even reach a higher state of the above mentioned form of detachment, namely the distancing of the soul from the body, which serves as its corporeal from. Such individuals would not only be living a carefree, detached life, but also gradually overcome their fear of death, as they would now perceive it as a liberation of the soul from its corporeal structure, erasing a huge element of anxiety that a majority suffer from.

As the process of detachment has been explored as discussed, now one can comprehend what it means to be a free individual. Individuals who have mastered at least the first two stages of detachment, namely abstract, societal and material, who are comfortable with being themselves, are free. Being yourself in this context is not simply identifying one’s flaws and positive qualities, while embracing the two. It doesn’t merely mean the acceptance of oneself and conducting themselves accordingly. In this case, individuals must feel comfortable being who they are, and that is being human - that is being comfortable with the removal of all those layers, without clinging onto identity, nationality, family and other aspects, and simply accepting that one is nothing less than an animated corpse.

Contrary to popular belief, humans have no purpose, and if detachment is a task that requires to be classified, then yes, the purpose of all human beings is to embark upon the process of detachment, and strip themselves of everything, including the layer, which we ‘assume’ form the entirety of our identity. It is to achieve the realization that what we have, is in fact not what we have.

If we don’t have a particular purpose, and we are not unique in our issues and identity, and if our actions and experienced events lack cosmic significance when viewed in relation to the bigger scheme of things, we might wonder what it is that we have to be grateful for. A majority, when asked this question immediately state that it’s their family, spouse, children, and occasionally a few go on to state that it’s their friends and career that give them a reason to express gratitude and continue living. This is quite a detrimental approach as such elements are extremely fluid in nature, and can negatively impact our state of being if it meets with an abrupt end. Ideally, when such a question is asked, the answer that should automatically pop up is ‘our breath’.

What many fail to realize is that once all those layers of detachment are shed, we are nothing but an animated living body. The only thing that makes our living body different from a corpse is our breath. For this very reason, our breath happens to be the only thing that we cannot live without. Not our family, reputation, status, job or career. It doesn’t mean that one should not be grateful for family and friends, but one should remember that one’s breath is the priority, and happens to be the very thing that allows us to experience such facets in our life, and thus should be the thing that we remain grateful for.

 

“Often in the endless search for purpose and fulfillment in life, we tend to forget that our purpose is to simply live and let go" - the hopeless pessimist

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Knowing That What You Have Is Not What You Have

  “Purpose is the essential element of you. It is the reason you are on the planet at this particular time in history. Your very existence i...